Supreme Court of North Carolina December 7, 1982, 350A82 (State v. Tate)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-12-1982
MARTIN, Justice.
The trial judge would not permit the defendant to testify concerning a conversation she had with Donald Watson upon entering the garage. Upon voir dire the defendant stated that had she been allowed to do so, she would have testified:
When I entered Mr. Watson’s office and I pushed the bag across and sat down on the corner of his desk and I
*244
started to talk to him about when he could possibly repaint the roof of my car, and Don told me, he said, “I have some urgent business to take care of.” He said, “If you’re going up to the barbecue stand with my brother to eat lunch, as soon as I get finished with it, I’ll be right, come up there with you and I’ll be glad to come up with a date we can repaint your car.” So he rushed me, he literally rushed me out of the office, and he said there was a guy waiting outside and he had something to take care of.
The Court of Appeals held that the trial judge’s exclusion of this testimony was error and that it prejudiced the defendant because it was the only evidence tending to show why the defendant left the garage so quickly. We find this holding erroneous because, although the trial judge did err in excluding the testimony, there is no reasonable possibility that had the testimony been allowed into evidence a different result would have been reached at trial. N.C. Gen. Stat. § 15A-1443(a) (1978).
The Court of Appeals correctly held that the defendant’s excluded testimony as to what Donald Watson said to her would have been admissible to show why defendant left the building so quickly. The statements of one person to another are admissible to explain the subsequent conduct of the person to whom the statements were made.
State v. White,
298 N.C. 430, 259 S.E. 2d 281 (1979);
State v. Potter,
295 N.C. 126, 244 S.E. 2d 397 (1978);
State v. Irick,
291 N.C. 480, 231 S.E. 2d 833 (1977).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit