District Court, D. Massachusetts August 25, 1982, Civ. A. 81-0004-N (National Women's Health Network, Inc. v. A. H. Robins Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-08-1982
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
DAVID S. NELSON, District Judge.
This is another of the many cases arising out of the manufacture and sale of an intrauterine device (IUD) known as the Dai-kon Shield by defendant A. H. Robins Company. Plaintiffs include two women allegedly injured by the device, their husbands, and two organizations affected by the dangers of the Daikon Shield. In addition to the couples’ claims for damages, plaintiffs seek certification of a class action for injunctive relief on behalf of all users and former users of the Daikon Shield. The relief requested would require Robins to indemnify former users for the costs of removal. With regard to present users, Robins would be required to conduct an identification and notification campaign, warning them directly of the risks of continuing use. In those cases where the user then opted for removal of the Daikon Shield, Robins would again be required to pay the costs. As plaintiffs have characterized the desired relief, it would amount to a worldwide recall of the Daikon Shield.
Robins has filed three motions to dismiss. These motions, respectively, challenge the subject matter jurisdiction of the court, the standing of all plaintiffs to raise claims on behalf of the putative class, and the availability of declaratory and injunctive relief, punitive damages and attorney’s fees. In addition to the motion to certify a class, plaintiffs filed a motion for a preliminary injunction. The parties have urged different procedures in considering these motions. Plaintiffs have suggested a consolidated consideration of the motions to dismiss, the motion to certify a class, and the motion for a preliminary injunction. Robins, on the other hand, has advocated a sequential consideration of the pending motions, starting with the motions to dismiss.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit