District Court, N.D. Illinois January 29, 1982, 81 C 36 (Anton v. Lehpamer)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-01-1982

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

SHADUR, District Judge.

Stanley Anton (“Anton”) sues (1) Downers Grove police officer Glen Lehpamer (“Lehpamer”) for the alleged use of excessive force in arresting Anton and (2) other defendants for their alleged failure to give Anton adequate medical treatment for an injury he claims he received during the arrest. Lehpamer has counterclaimed for assault and intentional infliction of emotional harm, based on Anton’s claimed attempt to kill Lehpamer during the arrest. Anton has moved to dismiss the Counterclaim. For the reasons stated in this memorandum opinion and order Anton’s motion is denied.

Facts

1

On December 21, 1978 Lehpamer responded to a radio dispatch ordering him to investigate a domestic disturbance involving Anton. Lehpamer was warned Anton was carrying a loaded pistol.

When Lehpamer and other officers arrived at the scene and attempted to arrest Anton, Anton didn’t comply with requests to stop and raise his hands over his head, instead keeping them in his jacket pocket while walking menacingly toward Lehpamer. During the arrest Anton made repeated threats to kill Lehpamer. After having eventually complied with the hands-overhead request, Anton suddenly threw his cap at Lehpamer and dropped his hands toward his sides.

Lehpamer reasonably believed Anton was trying to go for a weapon. Lehpamer and supporting officers immediately restrained Anton and confiscated a loaded pistol found in his pocket. As a result of the incident Lehpamer was apprehensive as to his physical safety and has suffered severe emotional distress.

Policemen’s Job-Related Tort Actions Generally

Neither party has addressed an important threshold issue as to the viability of Lehpamer’s claims

2

: Can policémen bring job-related tort suits or are such actions barred by notions of assumption of risk or

*241

contributory negligence? That basic question does not admit of an easy answer.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.