District Court, W.D. Arkansas July 16, 1982, Civ. A. 81-4101 (Tyson v. Schweiker)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-07-1982

MEMORANDUM OPINION

H. FRANKLIN WATERS, Chief Judge.

Plaintiff seeks review of a final decision of the Secretary of Health and Human Services denying his claims for disability insurance and supplemental security income benefits. The sole issue before the Court is whether substantial evidence supports the Secretary’s decision.

Plaintiff was born on August 24, 1942, has a high school education, and work experiences as a laborer; from 1975 until June, 1980, he worked loading and unloading lumber. He alleges disability because of back pain, numbness in his left leg and feet, and a loss of grip strength.

The medical evidence revealed no objective cause for plaintiff’s complaints to the degree of severity alleged. Repeated back X-rays were normal, as was a myelogram. In the hearing decision the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) stated:

The Administrative Law Judge has considered the entire record in this case, the claimant’s age, education and work experience, along with his impairments, and it is determined that the claimant’s impairments are not of such severity that would prohibit him from engaging in substantial gainful activity.

In his findings, the ALJ denied benefits, rejecting plaintiff’s allegations because they were not “complemented or substantiated by objective medical findings.” This Court is well aware that the Eighth Circuit has made it clear that “ [t]he Secretary must give some consideration to subjective complaints even though they are not necessarily corroborated by objective findings.”

Brand v. Sec. of HEW,

623 F.2d 523, 526 (8th Cir. 1980). However, other than to state that a “claimant’s subjective complaints may be shown to be exaggerated by any inconsistency in claimant’s testimony and all other circumstances of the case,”

id.

at 526 n.3, the Court gave little guidance in aiding an ALJ or district court in evaluating subjective complaints.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.