Kentucky Supreme Court August 31, 1982 (Brown v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-08-1982

OPINION OF THE COURT

The appellant, James H. (Jim) Brown, III, and his brother, Mark Brown, were jointly indicted for the murder of Bryant Dudley. Cf. KRS 507.020. In a separate trial Mark was found guilty and sentenced to 20 years in prison. His conviction was affirmed by this court in

Brown v. Commonwealth,

Ky., 555 S.W.2d 252 (1977). That opinion will serve as a sufficient background for understanding this case without a detailed account of the evidence in this opinion.

Jim Brown’s separate trial also resulted in a verdict of guilty and a sentence of 20 years’ imprisonment, which gives rise to this belated appeal.

With two major differences the evidence in Jim’s trial was much the same as it was

*759

in Mark’s. Mark was done in by the testimony of Robert Collins, who said that Mark had confided in him and admitted that he and Jim had killed Dudley. This evidence, of course, was not admissible against Jim. In Jim’s trial, on the other hand, there was expert evidence that blood found on Jim’s boots was not his blood but could have been Dudley’s. That evidence was not introduced in Mark’s trial.

To summarize the events, it will be recalled that Mark strongly suspected that Dudley had stolen a quantity of marijuana from his apartment in Maysville, and was threatening to shoot him. On the night of Monday, May 17, 1976, Jim, Mark and Robert Collins went riding in Jim’s automobile and picked Dudley up. As they continued riding around with Jim driving, Mark displayed a .45-caliber pistol and, pointing it in the “general direction” of Dudley, questioned him with regard to the theft of drugs from Mark’s apartment. Collins became apprehensive and asked that he be taken back to his car, which was done. When Collins parted company with them, Mark, Jim and Dudley were still together. On the next night, Tuesday, May 18, 1976, Jim and Mark were in Jim’s car on 4th Street in Maysville and indicated to Chan Warner and Earl Black that they were looking for Dudley.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.