Court of Appeals of Texas May 21, 1982, 20958 (Concrete Construction Supply, Inc. v. M. F. C., Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1982

FISH, Justice.

In this usury case, suit was brought by Concrete Construction Supply, Inc., a supplier, to recover for materials sold on open account to M.F.C., Inc., a contractor. A short time later, M.F.C. instituted suit against Concrete to obtain usury penalties for interest charges on the same account. The two suits were consolidated for a non-jury trial. Judgment was rendered in favor of M.F.C. for $4,533.96 (three times the amount of usurious interest charged), plus attorney’s fees of $4000 for services in the trial court and additional amounts in the event of an appeal. The judgment also forfeited all principal, interest and other charges on Concrete’s open account in the amount of $10,593.60. We agree with the court’s assessment of penalties, but modify the judgment by limiting the recovery to the amount prayed for by M.F.C.

In considering the seven points of error advanced by Concrete, we must decide (1) whether, under the facts of this case, M.F.C. was an obligor; (2) whether federal law has pre-empted the Texas law of usury that would otherwise control this case; (3) what difference there is, if any, between the amount of interest Concrete charged and the amount of interest allowed by law; and (4) whether M.F.C.⅛ recovery is limited to the amount prayed for in its pleadings. After determination of these issues, all of Concrete’s other contentions are resolved by formulas set out in the applicable usury laws.

I. WAS M.F.C. AN OBLIGOR?

In its first point of error Concrete contends that M.F.C. could not have been an obligor entitled to recover usury penalties because M.F.C. denied owing any debt to

*477

Concrete on the open account. Article 5069-1.06(1) of the Texas Revised Civil Statutes provides that:

“[A]ny person who contracts for, charges or receives interest which is greater than the amount authorized by this Subtitle, shall forfeit to the

obligor

three times the amount of usurious interest contracted for, charged or received. . .. ” (Vernon Supp.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.