Supreme Court of Alabama December 10, 1982, 81-128 (Eagerton v. Terra Resources, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-12-1982
This appeal necessitates further interpretation of the oil and gas severance tax statute which was the subject of Eagertonv. Exchange Oil and Gas Corporation, 404 So.2d 1 (Ala. 1981). The question is whether an exception in the statute swallows the rule as to gas producers. We hold that it does not, and reverse. Terra Resources, Inc. (Terra), Petroleum Corporation of Texas (PETCO), and other companies filed suit to recover oil and gas severance taxes paid under protest. After *Page 808 a remand by this Court,1 the circuit court ordered a refund of substantial amounts of the tax paid on gas production. Ralph P. Eagerton, Jr., as Commissioner of Revenue of the State of Alabama (the Commissioner), appealed. The above-named companies filed briefs as appellees2; we shall refer to them as the gas producers. In 1979 the Alabama Legislature passed an Act, "To amend Code of 1975, Sections 40-20-2 and 40-20-8, so as to increase therate of tax; to provide further for distribution of the proceeds of the tax; and to provide certain exemptions from the increased rate." 1979 Ala. Acts No. 79-434, p. 687 (emphasis added).3 Prior to this act, the title of § 40-20-2 was "Levy and amount of tax upon business of producing or severing oil orgas from soil, etc., generally." (Emphasis added.) Nevertheless, the gas-producing appellees argue that the "increase" enacted in Act No. 79-434 of the tax upon the business of producing oil or gas only applies to gas production if a gas well produces 26 barrels or more of oil per day. In other words, Act No. 79-434 raised the four percent (4%) previously found in § 40-20-2 to six percent (6%). One of the exemptions mentioned in the title as set out above reads, "All wells producing less than 26 barrels of oil per day shall be taxed at the rate of four per centum (4%) of the gross value of said oil or gas at the point of production.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit