Missouri Court of Appeals March 9, 1982, 43510 (Meeks v. Berkbuegler)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-03-1982

*25

SNYDER, Judge.

Plaintiff appeals from a granting of defendant-respondent State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company’s

1

motion for directed verdict at the close of appellant’s evidence. The action arose from an off-road accident between appellant’s motorcycle and defendant Richard Berkbue-gler’s dune buggy. Appellant sued respondent State Farm pursuant to the uninsured motor vehicle provision of appellant’s automobile liability insurance policy. Appellant’s claim against individual defendant Berkbuegler was dismissed without prejudice after State Farm’s motion for directed verdict was granted.

The trial court granted the motion for a directed verdict on the ground that “there is no coverage in this type of situation,” meaning coverage under the uninsured motorist section of the policy. This court agrees with the trial court and affirms the judgment.

Appellant argues the trial court erred in granting respondent’s motion for a directed verdict for three reasons. First, he says appellant’s evidence raised an issue of fact whether the dune buggy fit within the policy’s definition of an uninsured motor vehicle. Second, he argues the provision purportedly excluding the dune buggy from the definition of an uninsured motor vehicle is ambiguous and should be construed against respondent. Third, he maintains the exclusion is void as against public policy-

The accident occurred on June 7, 1977 on the grassy part of the Interstate 55 right-of-way near the Gasconade Street entrance ramp in St. Louis, Missouri. Appellant and Richard Berkbuegler were riding their vehicles up and down the hill located there. Appellant was riding a Kawasaki trail bike and Berkbuegler a four wheel dune buggy type vehicle, the exact nature of which is in dispute. Appellant, then age 15, suffered serious injuries in a collision between the two vehicles.

Berkbuegler assembled the dune buggy chassis from a kit he purchased from Che-nowth Racing Products, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.