Supreme Court of Louisiana October 29, 1982, 82-C-0640 (Robertson v. Gulf South Beverage, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-10-1982
421 So.2d 877 (1982) William ROBERTSON and Vicki C. Robertson v. GULF SOUTH BEVERAGE, INC. No. 82-C-0640. Supreme Court of Louisiana. October 18, 1982. Supplemental Opinion October 29, 1982. Rehearing Denied November 19, 1982. *878 D. Bert Garraway, Bart Eaton, R. Bruce Macmurdo, Percy, Macmurdo & Eaton, Baton Rouge, for applicant. Charles A. O'Brien, III, Franklin, Moore & Walsh, Baton Rouge, for respondents. BLANCHE, Justice. This suit arose out of an incident which occurred on April 22, 1978 when a 32 ounce returnable Pepsi-Cola bottle allegedly exploded and caused a serious injury to the wrist and hand of the plaintiff, Vicki C. Robertson. The bottle in question was purchased the day before the incident by plaintiff William Robertson and placed on the floor of the plaintiffs' pantry where it remained until the injury-causing incident the next day. At trial, Vicki testified that she opened the pantry door to retrieve a can of Crisco shortening when she suddenly felt a "sharp sting" in her left wrist and noticed blood spewing from a deep cut. As a result of the injury, which damaged a major nerve innervating her left hand, Vicki has a permanent claw-deformity and a 40 percent disability in the use of the hand. Before the accident, Vicki was employed by the State as a typist. The critical issue before the trial court was whether the bottle had spontaneously exploded or whether some external blow to the bottle caused the glass to fail. The trial court dismissed the plaintiffs' suit, finding as a matter of fact that the bottle failed as a result of an external blow of significant force and that the bottle did not spontaneously explode due to some internal pressure. The court of appeal affirmed, adopting as its opinion the written reasons assigned by the trial judge. In our opinion, it is not necessary for us to decide whether the bottle exploded spontaneously or whether it exploded as the result of some external force.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit