Michigan Court of Appeals March 3, 1982, Docket 53488 (Clark Equipment Co. v. Township of Leoni)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-03-1982
Bronson, P.J.
Petitioner appeals as of right from the Tax Tribunal’s determination of the value of its four parcels of real property located in Leoni Township, County of Jackson. The parcels of land are the site of a heavy industrial plant owned by petitioner. The four parcels were valued as a single entity and will be treated as such for purposes of this appeal. This appeal concerns the assessments of the subject realty and industrial plant for the years of 1978 and 1979. The Tax Tribunal found the true cash value of the property to be $8,487,766 for 1978 and $8,934,490 for 1979.
Petitioner’s appraiser offered only a market approach to valuation of the subject property. Under petitioner’s market analysis, the true cash value for each year was determined to be $5,000,000. The Tax Tribunal rejected petitioner’s market analysis, finding that the properties used by petitioner’s appraiser were not really comparable to the subject property. In reaching its valuation
*781
conclusions, the tribunal agreed with respondent’s appraiser that a replacement cost minus depreciation analysis was most likely to result in an accurate true cash value determination for the property. This holding by the tribunal is the subject of petitioner’s first assignment of error.
The Tax Tribunal found "that the best and most appropriate method of appraising an owner-occupied, on-going use industrial facility wherein the present use represents the highest and best use of the property For Assessment Purposes is to calculate its replacement (as distinct from reproduction) cost, allow for physical, functional and economic obsolescence (or depreciation) and add the land value to the appraisal”. Petitioner objects to this "value in use” approach as having no relationship to the usual selling price, which is the statutory touchstone for determining the cash value of a property. MCL 211.27; MSA 7.27.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit