Supreme Court of Alabama July 23, 1982, 81-558 (Ex Parte Bass)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-07-1982
417 So.2d 588 (1982) Ex parte Carl BASS. (In re Carl Bass v. State of Alabama) 81-558. Supreme Court of Alabama. July 23, 1982. Dennis N. Balske, Montgomery, for petitioner. No brief for respondent. PER CURIAM. WRIT DENIED. JONES, ALMON, SHORES, EMBRY, BEATTY and ADAMS, JJ., concur. TORBERT, C. J., and FAULKNER, J., dissent. TORBERT, Chief Justice (dissenting). I dissent and would grant review of petitioner's conviction on the issue of whether petitioner was denied effective assistance of counsel, in violation of Article I, § 6, of the Alabama Constitution and the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution. I believe this Court should examine the standard presently used by our state courts when presented with a claim of incompetency of legal counsel in light of the recent decision of Harris v. Oliver, 645 F.2d 327 (5th Cir. 1981). The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has adopted a "reasonably effective assistance" standard, while our courts, when faced with a claim of incompetent legal counsel, have traditionally used the standard of "whether the trial was reduced to a farce, sham or mockery of justice." While the Court of Criminal Appeals is correct when it states that Alabama state courts are not bound by the decisions of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, it is also true that federal courts have the power to *589 review state court decisions through a petition for habeas corpus. A federal court will therefore review a claim of denial of effective assistance of counsel by the Fifth Circuit standardnot the standard presently used by our courts. Much has been said about the interference by the federal courts in state court decisions in criminal cases. But as long as we have a legal standard different from the federal standard, we have no reason to complain about federal courts accepting collateral attacks against state court judgments.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit