United States Bankruptcy Appellate Panel for the Ninth Circuit September 9, 1982, BAP No. AZ-81-1061LHK, Bankruptcy No. B-20-2090PHX-VM, Ad. No. 80-0681-VM (Marcus v. McKesson Drug Co. (In Re Mistura, Inc.))

Also known as

United States · · · 09-09-1982

combined-opinion

22 B.R. 60 (1982) In re MISTURA, INC., Debtor. Lee MARCUS and Ann Marcus, Appellants, v. McKESSON DRUG COMPANY, a division of Foremost-McKesson, Inc., a Maryland corporation, Appellee. BAP No. AZ-81-1061LHK, Bankruptcy No. B-20-2090PHX-VM, Ad. No. 80-0681-VM. United States Bankruptcy Appellate Panels of the Ninth Circuit. Argued September 16, 1981. Decided June 24, 1982. Opinion on Denial of Rehearing September 9, 1982. J. Lawrence Dunlavey, Sidney B. Wolfe, Wolfe & Harris, P.A., Phoenix, Ariz., for appellants. *61 Peter Rathwell, Snell & Wilmer, Phoenix, Ariz., for appellee. Before LASAROW, HUGHES and KATZ, Bankruptcy Judges. Opinion on Denial of Rehearing September 9, 1982. See 24 B.R. 586. OPINION HUGHES, Bankruptcy Judge: This appeal questions the trial court's construction of Arizona's Commercial Code, its evidentiary rulings and, ultimately, its order holding that appellants' security interest in personal property is subordinate to appellee's. I Mr. and Mrs. Marcus, the appellants, sold a drug store to Mistura, Inc., taking back a security interest in the personal property for the unpaid balance of the purchase price. They also leased the business premises to Mistura. Subsequently, Mistura sought financing from a number of sources and eventually obtained a loan from McKesson Drug Company, which was secured by the same personal property. Mistura filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy but does not assert an equity in the collateral. The only question is the relative priority of the security interests held by the Marcuses and McKesson. Absent the effect of a particular statutory provision, it is conceded that McKesson would prevail because it filed its financing statement with the Secretary of State prior to the Marcuses. As to all of the collateral except fixtures, central filing with the Secretary of State is required. A.R.S. 44-3140(A)(3), U.C.C. 9-401(1)(c).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.