United States Bankruptcy Appellate Panel for the Ninth Circuit September 17, 1982, BAP Nos. NC-81-1028-GVL, NC-81-1059-GVL, Bankruptcy No. 4-79-03471HS, Adv. No. 4-80-0192AH (Good Leasing, Inc. v. Finkel (In Re Finkel))
Also known as
United States · · · 17-09-1982
*18
OPINION
GEORGE, Bankruptcy Judge:
Before the Panel, by way of two consolidated appeals, is a question of whether the trial court erred in assessing the extent of the nondischargeable debt owed to the appellant by the appellee-debtor in these proceedings. We AFFIRM the trial court’s judgment.
I. BACKGROUND
Sometime before 1977, the appellee, Steve Q. Z. Finkel, became interested in converting a restaurant facility into a disco-teque. Prior to that time, Mr. Finkel had dealt with the appellant, both personally and as general manager of a business entity known as Richardson Security Company, in the lease of a number of motor vehicles. In dealing with Good Leasing, Inc., [hereinafter “Good Leasing”] Mr. Finkel had worked primarily through one John Cross, an agent of the appellant.
In anticipation of the need to finance his discoteque operation, Mr. Finkel approached Mr. Cross with the idea of obtaining funds from the Good Leasing. (Mr. Cross was subsequently given some $2,000 by Mr. Finkel, ostensibly for having provided his services as an intermediary in this series of transactions.)
Three “sale and lease-back” agreements were eventually entered into between the above-named parties. Only the first of these agreements is of concern to the Panel at this time. Under this first agreement, Good Leasing advanced some $50,000 to the appellee through one Harold E. Macken-thun, who had been employed by Mr. Finkel to do the construction work on the project. Prior to making such an advance, however, two distinct bills of sale were issued. First, on February 15,1977, Mr. Mackenthun gave Mr. Finkel a $50,000 bill of sale for the kitchen equipment to be purchased with the advance. Then, on February 28, 1977, Mr. Finkel gave Good Leasing a $50,000 bill of sale for the same equipment. Finally, on March 1, 1977, Good Leasing issued Mr. Mackenthun a check for the $50,000 amount, and Mackenthun endorsed the check over to Mr. Finkel.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit