District Court, N.D. Mississippi January 13, 1982, GC 80-194-WK-O, GC 80-215-WK-O (Spragins v. Huber Farm Service, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-01-1982

MEMORANDUM ORDER

READY, Chief Judge.

In these consolidated diversity actions, two defendants, Hans and Josef Huber, both of whom are Swiss nationals, have petitioned the court for an order disqualifying the law firm of Lake, Tindall, Hunger and Thackston (Lake, Tindall) from representing plaintiffs herein because of alleged conflict of interest arising out of the attorneys’ prior professional relations with the Hubers. Lake, Tindall, through separate counsel, challenges the petition and asserts that there is no basis for disqualification. The court held a hearing on the petition on November 24, 1981, at which Lake, Tindall, its counsel, and counsel for petitioners appeared, argued the issues, and submitted documentary evidence in support of their positions. The court now embarks on the “painstaking factual analysis” required under applicable law.

See Duncan v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith,

646 F.2d 1020, 1021 (5 Cir. 1981).

I.

In August 1977, Vivian Reed, a client of Lake, Tindall’s partner Charles S. Tindall, went to Tindall’s law office at Greenville, Mississippi, with Josef Huber (Josef) and Kay Taylor (Taylor) to discuss a sale of Forkland Plantation by Reed and her daughter to Huber Farm Service, Inc., a Tennessee corporation (Tennessee Huber), in which Hans and Josef Huber had a financial interest. Tennessee Huber was represented throughout the real estate transaction by separate counsel. A sales contract was signed by Reed and Josef, acting as secretary of Tennessee Huber, on August 24,1977. A term of the contract recognized that Chester Kellems, Forkland’s tenant in possession, had first right of refusal to purchase the property on the same terms as provided by the sales agreement with Tennessee Huber. When Kellems timely exercised his option, Taylor protested to Reed that Kellems was purchasing Forkland not for himself but for Felix Bibus, the party to whom Tennessee Huber expected to sell the property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.