Supreme Court of Vermont September 7, 1982, 444-81 (Eddy v. Watson)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-09-1982
*579
Per Curiam.
Defendant-appellant Nancy Watson appeals from the trial court’s decision and resulting judgment holding her liable to plaintiff-appellee Doris Eddy for the reasonable value of boarding two horses. We affirm.
Since the parties waived findings of fact we must assume that the trial court made all findings necessary to support the result.
Chittenden Trust Co.
v.
Maryanski,
138 Vt. 240, 243, 415 A.2d 206, 208 (1980). In October 1978 defendant brought two horses to plaintiff’s stables and left them in her care. The animals were fed and cared for by plaintiff from that date until sometime in May of 1981. Not surprisingly, the question of compensation soon reared its head.
On December 17, 1979, plaintiff formally demanded payment from defendant. None was forthcoming, and plaintiff brought suit in April of 1980 alleging that she was entitled to recover damages on either the basis of (1) an express contract, or (2) unjust enrichment. On the other hand, defendant claimed that plaintiff was to have the use of the horses for training purposes in lieu of monetary compensation.
After a jury-waived trial the trial court held in favor of the plaintiff and ruled that although there had been no express contract, plaintiff was entitled to recover the fair value of boarding the horses — $2.00 per day — on the basis of an “implied contract.” Damages were, however, limited to a reasonable period, i.e., from the date the horses were brought to plaintiff until the date of the first demand for payment. Defendant appeals, claiming that the judgment is unsupported by the evidence.
At the outset we note that although the court employed the term “implied contract” in its opinion, it is clear that the judgment is grounded on the theory of quasi contract. Under this theory “the law raises a promise to pay when a party receives a benefit and the retention of the benefit would be inequitable.”
Wilson
v.
Alexander,
139 Vt. 279, 280, 428 A.2d 1089, 1090 (1981).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit