District Court, D. New Jersey April 27, 1982, Civ. 81-863 (Union County Jail Inmates v. Scanlon)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-04-1982

OPINION

HAROLD A. ACKERMAN, District Judge.

It is no secret that crime is one of the most serious problems facing this country.

*996

People properly perceive it as a disease of epidemic proportions affecting the very well-being of society.

1

It is understandable that the public, acting through its appointed and elected representatives, has attempted to respond forcefully by apprehending, prosecuting, convicting, and in appropriate circumstances, incarcerating the perpetrators of crime.

Incarceration, especially for violent criminals, is increasingly considered to be the appropriate response to criminal behavior.

2

For this reason, the legislatures of many jurisdictions have reacted to this epidemic through the passage of new laws significantly stiffening penalties to be meted out to offenders and adjusting parole guidelines. New Jersey is no exception. The new criminal code has already had an appreciable impact on the number and length of incarcerative sentences.

3

As an inevitable consequence of this war on crime, there has been an enormous increase in the population of correctional facilities in this country.

4

Again, New Jersey is no exception.

5

The erection of new correctional facilities to accommodate the increased jail and prison populations has been urged by many responsible leaders including Chief Justice Warren E. Burger.

6

To date, new construction has not kept pace with the demand for prison space.

Institutions have become not just crowded but overcrowded. The reduced habitability of correctional facilities has in turn spawned a flood of lawsuits by prisoners in the federal courts.

7

The complaints alleging violations of the United States Constitution paint an egregious picture of the conditions of confinement in both state and federal institutions. The allegations

*997

implicate the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments with respect to the confinement of those who stand accused but who are not free on bail (pretrial detainees).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.