Court of Appeals of Maryland July 1, 1982, [No. 123, September Term, 1981.] (In Re Special Investigation No. 185)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1982

Rodowsky, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

Md. Code (1957, 1982 Repl. Vol.), Art. 27, § 592A (a) provides that "[t]he State’s attorney may issue a summons for a witness for the purpose of obtaining evidence to prepare an information.”

1

In this case we shall hold § 592A does not authorize a summons in order to investigate whether or not a crime has occurred. Rather, the statute, at a minimum, requires that the State’s Attorney have probable cause to believe that a crime has taken place which he presently intends to charge by way of a criminal information.

The issue presented here is precipitated by a summons

*654

duces tecum issued by the Attorney General, acting through an Assistant Attorney General assigned to the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit of the Attorney General’s Office. Pursuant to Md. Const., art. V, § 3, Acting Governor Blair Lee, III on December 20, 1978 and Governor Harry Hughes on November 21, 1979 had authorized and directed the Attorney General, "acting with full powers, rights and privileges possessed by a State’s Attorney, to investigate and, where appropriate, prosecute” violations of criminal laws arising out of, or relating to, the State’s Medicaid Program. The appellant in this case is a licensed optometrist. On March 12, 1981 the Attorney General issued a summons duces tecum to the appellant, under the recited authority of § 592A, requiring the production of appellant’s records relating to 100 specifically named Medicaid patients. These records were produced. By a letter of April 9, 1981, which referred to the prior agreement of appellant’s counsel, the Attorney General requested records relating to 200 additional, specifically named, Medicaid patients. These records were furnished. Then, by summons duces tecum of April 30,1981, the Attorney General directed the appellant to produce his records of 1733 additional, specifically named, Medicaid patients. Appellant moved to quash.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.