Supreme Court of New Hampshire June 9, 1982, 81-281 (Spaulding v. Concord General Mutual Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-06-1982

Batchelder, J.

This case involves the question of whether the defendant-insurer’s policy with the plaintiff covers the vehicle that the plaintiff was driving at the time of an accident. Upon the Master’s

(Charles T. Gallagher,

Esq.) recommendation, the Superior Court

(Johnson,

J.) found that there was no coverage under the policy. We affirm.

The plaintiff, Gary M. Spaulding, at the time in question, had an insurance policy with Concord General Mutual Insurance Company (Concord General) covering a 1973 Opel. On October 5, 1979, while driving a 1966 Ford Econoline van, the plaintiff collided

*516

with a parked automobile owned by a Mr. Richard Saia. When Mr. Saia sued. Mr. Spaulding, Concord General denied coverage. The plaintiff then brought this action for a declaratory judgment in superior court.

The Ford van in question was registered to a Steven Hoyt. It had been purchased approximately a year and a half before the accident, and had been parked primarily in the plaintiffs driveway. The plaintiff used the van frequently and contributed to its upkeep. Because Mr. Hoyt was in jail from July 27, 1979, to November 26, 1979,, he was unable to use the van during that time. The plaintiff said he was driving the van during early October 1979, because his Opel was uninspected. The Opel, however, passed inspection three days after the accident.

The plaintiff was insured under the Concord General policy when driving an

owned

or

non-owned automobile.

An

owned automobile

is defined by the policy as “a private passenger . . . automobile described in this policy for which a specific premium charge indicates that coverage is afforded . . . [or] a temporary substitute automobile.” A

temporary substitute automobile

is further defined as “any automobile . . . , not owned by the named insured, while temporarily used with the permission of the owner as a substitute for the owned automobile . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.