Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit March 25, 1982, 81-1366 (Richland Plantation Company v. Justiss-Mears Oil Company, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-03-1982

TATE, Circuit Judge:

This Texas diversity suit involves the construction of an agreement to pay an additional (or overriding) royalty in the event of production, beyond that provided by a mineral lease entered into the same day between the parties. The defendant producer-lessee (“Justiss”) appeals from the district court’s ruling that additional royalty payments are due to the plaintiff landowner-lessor (“Richland”) under the additional-royalty agreement. Justiss, the appellant defendant, principally contends that the district court erred in finding ambiguity in the additional-royalty agreement, if construed together with the simultaneously executed lease, and in thus admitting extrinsic evidence to prove the intent of the parties.

We affirm, finding (a) that the district court correctly held that the agreement was ambiguous and that extrinsic evidence was properly admissible to aid in its construction and (b) that the district court was not clearly erroneous in its finding that the parties intended that the additional royalty not be subject to the proportionate reduction clause of the lease that was applicable to royalties provided by the lease itself.

The Factual Context

On November 11, 1975, after preliminary negotiations as to the percentage of royalties payable, Richland and Justiss entered into a mineral lease covering 4,251 acres of Richland’s land. At the same time they signed an unrecorded letter agreement providing for the payment of an additional (or overriding) royalty in the event of production. At the time, Richland owned only one-half of the mineral interests in the land in question.

The substantial issue in this appeal is whether a proportionate reduction clause in the lease itself, requiring proportionate re

*156

duction in the lease-provided royalty payments if the lessor owned less than the whole mineral rights, was

also

applicable to the additional royalty specified by the supplemental letter agreement to be payable in the event of production.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.