Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit March 31, 1982, 80-1579 (Lloyd Biggle, Jr. And Damon Knight v. Harper & Row Publishers, Inc., a Delaware Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-03-1982

LIVELY, Circuit Judge.

In this diversity action the district court granted summary judgment for the defendant on one count of the complaint and certified the case for immediate appeal pursuant to Rule 54(b), F.R.Civ.P. The question in the case is whether certain writings relied upon by the plaintiffs were sufficient to satisfy the requirements of the statute of frauds. The district court held that the writings were not sufficient and dismissed the plaintiffs’ breach of contract claim.

I.

The plaintiffs Biggie and Knight approached the defendant Harper & Row with the idea of publishing an anthology of science fiction stories which would be used primarily in high school and college courses. The entire anthology as proposed was to consist of eight volumes and a teacher’s manual. In discussions with the plaintiffs, Hugh Van Dusen, the senior editor in charge of Harper & Row “Perennial Paperback” books, suggested that a series of four rather than eight volumes might be preferable. Nevertheless, on May 16, 1975 Van Dusen sent an inter-office memorandum to Elizabeth Jakab, an editor of the Perennial Paperback books, in which he stated, “I talked to Biggie and agreed to do the 8 books.” The memorandum also stated, “We need a separate contract for each book . . .,” and contained directions for forwarding contracts to the plaintiffs and terms of payment of advances. The memorandum was typed and unsigned. It was from “Hugh” to “Elis” and referred to “Damon Knight and Lloyd Biggie Science Fiction Project.” It is reproduced in full as Appendix Exhibit A to this opinion.

On June 2, 1975 Elizabeth Jakab wrote Lloyd Biggie a letter in which she enclosed “the first of the contracts that will be coming from us for the volume tentatively entitled YESTERDAY PLUS TWO.” On July 28, 1975 Ms. Jakab wrote to Biggie acknowledging receipt of three contracts, identified by titles, and forwarding three additional contracts covering different volumes,' again identified by title.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.