Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit September 13, 1982, 82-1187 (Clarence Douglas Ellison v. Jerry De La Rosa, Jr.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-09-1982

GEE, Circuit Judge:

Appellant filed this purported section 1983 action in the district court against his appointed trial attorney and his appointed appellate counsel, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief, as well as large actual and punitive damages from each. He sought declaratory relief that their actions had violated his constitutional rights and injunctive relief, requiring “the defendants to immediately stop being ineffective . . . [and] appear before the Texas State Bar for proper disciplinary action . . . . ” Appellant’s claims were that (1) his trial counsel was ineffective for allowing two fundamentally defective indictments to be prosecuted against him, and (2) his appellate counsel was ineffective for failing to urge the invalidity of the indictments on appeal and also for failing to urge the ineffectiveness of his trial counsel.

The district court denied relief, adopting the report of the magistrate, who found that there was no legal basis on which to hold the defendants liable for any alleged “wrong” and that the court had no authority to grant the relief appellant sought. With respect to his allegations that challenged the fact or validity of his criminal conviction and resulting confinement, the court dismissed the action without prejudice for appellant first to exhaust his remedies in the state courts.

Appellant is presently a prisoner in the custody of the Texas Department of Corrections on an enhanced sentence of 30 years for 1980 state burglary convictions. His appeal of his latest conviction was pending in the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals at the time this federal suit was filed.

The ruling of the district court was correct. Appellant’s allegations, apart from the purely conclusory claim that counsel’s representation “was in all things ineffective,” focused on the alleged invalidity of the indictments upon which he was convicted.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.