Supreme Judicial Court of Maine February 25, 1982 (Carson v. Town of Oakland)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-02-1982
VIOLETTE, Justice.
On April 30, 1980, plaintiff Veda Carson, a sixty year old resident of the Town of Oakland for more than nineteen years, applied to the Oakland Town Manager for a grant of general assistance funds in the amount of ten dollars to purchase food. Her monthly income at that time consisted of $218.20 in Social Security insurance benefits and was supplemented by an allotment of $63.00 worth of food stamps. The Town Manager asked her to consent to a “home visit” for the purpose of verifying her need for food. She refused his request, and he denied her application for assistance because she would “not permit verification of need.” Plaintiff then exercised her right to request a hearing before the Fair Hearing Authority of the Town of Oakland. See 22 M.R.S.A. § 4507 (1980). The Fair Hearing Authority, in its decision, stated that after
reviewpng] the decision of the Town Manager .... The Board . . . voted to uphold the Manager’s decision .... A request by the Town Manager to make a home visit to verify the needs was denied. Thus, he was not able to make a proper verification of any need and the Board finds his decision was within the guidelines.
Plaintiff commenced this action to obtain judicial review of the decision of the Fair Hearing Authority. The Superior Court, Kennebec County, denied the appeal, holding that the Town Manager had reasonably concluded that without a home visit plaintiff's need could not be verified, and had acted in accordance with a town ordinance *171permitting denial of assistance due to lack of verification. The lower court also ruled that “[t]he Fair Hearing Authority was not required to hold a new hearing on all issues .... They needed only to consider whether the Town Manager’s decision was correct, based on all the circumstances of the claim before him.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit