Supreme Judicial Court of Maine May 4, 1982 (Lewiston Firefighters Ass'n v. City of Lewiston)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-05-1982
ROBERTS, Justice.
Following our decision in Lewiston Firefighters Association, Local 785 v. City of Lewiston, Me., 354 A.2d 154 (1976) [Lewiston 1], the plaintiffs returned to Superior Court to pursue their claim regarding their statutory right to parity pay. After receiving documentary evidence and the testimony of one witness, the Superior Court concluded that “the plaintiffs are not entitled to pay supplements or any of the other relief they seek and that plaintiffs shall recover nothing.” Plaintiffs appeal from that decision. We affirm the judgment of the Superior Court.
In 1965 the Legislature amended the Lewiston City Charter to provide that firefighting personnel “shall receive a weekly rate of compensation in an amount no less than that of equivalent officers and privates in the Lewiston police department.” P. & S.L., 1965, ch. 33, § 1. The amendment became effective January 2,1966. In 1973 the plaintiffs, relying on allegations that the City had violated the parity pay provisions, brought suit seeking damages, injunctive and declaratory relief. Adverse decisions led both parties to appeal to this Court. Lewiston 1,354 A.2d at 156-57. We held that the Municipal Public Employees Labor Relations Law [MPELRL], 26 M.R. S.A. §§ 961-72, had, by implication, repealed the parity pay provision amendment to the Lewiston City Charter, id. at 162, and that from and after the effective date of the MPELRL, October 1, 1969, the firefighters’ statutory and contract rights to parity pay were unenforceable. Id. at 162-63. We further held, however, that any contractual right to parity pay should properly be determined by arbitration, and that a statutory right to parity pay did exist until October 1, 1969, and was judicially enforceable subject to the statute of limitations. Id. at 163-64, 166-68.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit