Supreme Court of Rhode Island June 18, 1982, No. 79-341-Appeal (Homecraft Builders, Inc. v. Samos)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-06-1982
OPINION
MURRAY, Justice.
The plaintiff, Homecraft Builders, Inc., brought this action in Superior Court against the defendant, Oscar Samos. The plaintiff claimed damages in the amount of $100,000 which included (a) $8,000, plus interest, lent to the defendant; (b) the unpaid balance owed for the renovation of the defendant’s residence; and (c) reimbursement for the partial construction of an office building for the defendant. The defendant, in turn, filed a counterclaim against the plaintiff, seeking damages for the cost of repairs to a portion of the construction and for the increased cost occasioned by his subsequent hiring of another contractor to complete the office building.
*1055After the trial, the jury denied defendant’s counterclaim and returned a verdict of $37,572.75 for plaintiff. The defendant then moved for a new trial on all issues. The trial justice, finding that the verdict was excessive and that defendant’s counsel had prejudiced his client, ordered a new trial on the issue of damages only. The plaintiff and defendant have both appealed to this court from the order of the trial justice.
In 1974, plaintiff performed several home-renovation projects for defendant and his wife at their residence in Cranston. Ralph N. Sweet (hereinafter referred to as “plaintiff”), the manager, sole stockholder, and officer of plaintiff corporation, testified at trial that defendant and his wife had agreed to pay $2,150 for the last of these projects. According to plaintiff, only $1,000 of this was paid, and defendant orally promised to include the remaining $1,150 in the price of a construction contract for a medical office building that defendant proposed to have plaintiff build in Pawtucket.
The contract entered into by the parties was the subject of lengthy, conflicting, and often confusing testimony. However, a careful review of the transcript reveals the essential elements of plaintiff’s claim.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit