Court of Appeals of Texas February 25, 1982, No. 1464 (Hunt Oil Co. v. Moore)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-02-1982
SUMMERS, Justice.
This is an appeal from a judgment of the trial court (1) declaring a certain oil and gas lease terminated, (2) finding the leasehold title vested in the appellee, (3) granting to appellee an accounting, and (4) awarding damages based thereon.
The initial question before us is whether we have jurisdiction to hear this appeal. The appellee, Willis Moore, Trustee, claims we are without jurisdiction because appellants, Hunt Oil Company, et al (Hunt Oil), failed to timely perfect their appeal.
We agree with appellee and dismiss the appeal for want of jurisdiction.
Some years after this case was originally brought, both sides filed motions for summary judgments. The trial court held hearings on these motions and on April 5, 1979, signed a judgment terminating the lease held by Hunt Oil as of May 16, 1962. The trial court further ordered that the cloud on appellee’s title to the subject property be removed and that Hunt Oil render an accounting to the appellee for all of the oil, gas and other minerals produced from the unit which was attributable to the undivided one-tenth mineral interest of the appel-lee. Hunt Oil’s motion for summary judgment was denied.
The accounting procedures were commenced over the next year, and on May 16, 1980, a so-called “Final Judgment” was signed. This judgment was identical to the judgment signed on April 5, 1979, except that Hunt Oil was ordered to pay appellee $377,058.52 which sum was arrived at as a result of the accounting. It was from this May 16, 1980, judgment that Hunt Oil appealed. Appellee claims that the true final judgment was the one signed on April 5, 1979, and Hunt Oil, therefore, failed to timely perfect its appeal.
The main issue involved here is whether the ordering of an accounting makes the judgment interlocutory and not appealable. In Ferguson v. Ferguson, 161 Tex. 184, 338 S.W.2d 945 (1960), the Supreme Court was faced with a similar issue.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit