Court of Appeals of Texas May 5, 1982, No. 2-81-139-CR (Reed v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-05-1982

OPINION

HOLMAN, Justice.

This appeal is from conviction of murder. Y.T.C.A.Penal Code sec. 19.02.

The jury assessed punishment at 40 years imprisonment.

We affirm.

Appellant complains that the prosecutor made prejudicial comments to the jury about (1) the punishment range, (2) the veracity of appellant’s testimony at trial and (3) appellant’s right to remain silent.

The evidence is that on August 10, 1979, appellant shot and killed Domingo Najera with a 16 gauge shotgun as they stood on the parking lot of the Red Garter Club in Fort Worth.

That episode was the culmination of their argument over a “$5 or $10” wager made while appellant and Najera were drinking beer and playing pool with friends inside the club.

Appellant’s girl friend, Patricia Bogan, was among those present.

Witnesses testified that appellant had exited the club after the initial argument and was seen fifteen minutes later on the parking lot with the shotgun.

When he learned that appellant had returned, Najera exited the club and went to the parking lot, where the argument resumed.

During the quarrel, which was loud enough to attract the attention of apartment residents across the adjacent street, the gun discharged, killing Najera.

Appellant fled the scene after the shooting.

Later that day, Patricia Bogan, who resided at appellant’s apartment, gave police officers permission to enter the apartment, and there they found the shotgun.

Three days later, appellant surrendered to police.

Appellant testified that after he left the initial argument and arrived at his apartment, he realized that his girlfriend was still at the club; so he returned to the club with a loaded shotgun in order to “seize her from the bar.”

He further testified that, as a black man, he felt a need to be armed, because he knew another black man had been stabbed at the club a week earlier.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.