Missouri Court of Appeals December 14, 1982, No. WD 33514 (State v. Elam)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-12-1982

CLARK, Judge.

Randy Elam was convicted of the offense of passing a bad check, § 570.120, RSMo 1978, and he was sentenced as a persistent offender to a term of five years. Reversed.

On this appeal, Elam contends the evidence produced by the state made no sub-missible case against him. We agree and therefore consider only incidentally his second point that the state’s verdict directing instruction was erroneous because essential elements of the offense were omitted. The two points are, however, associated because the proof and the instruction were both deficient in the same respect.

The transaction in question was one in which Elam and a female companion, Jacqueline J. Cordillo, purchased a used truck on July 15, 1981 from Briggs-Cupp Chevrolet in Marceline. The only witness to testify about the purchase was Bob Dean Cupp, a proprietor of the business. According to Cupp, Elam and Cordillo came to the automobile agency to buy a vehicle and selected a 1973 Chevrolet pick-up. The price agreed upon was $2,250.00 to which was added $23.00 for gasoline to fill the truck’s fuel tank. Cordillo made out a check in the amount of $2,273.00 drawn on her account at the Macon-Atlanta Bank in Macon, Missouri and delivered the check to Cupp. At the request of Elam and Cordillo, papers for processing the vehicle title were made out in the names of Randy and Jacqueline Elam, the explanation being offered that the two had been married only weeks before and Jacqueline had not yet changed the name on her bank account.

The Cordillo check was deposited in due course by Briggs-Cupp but was returned within a few days by the drawee bank because Cordillo had insufficient funds in her account. Cupp promptly confronted Elam and Cordillo but was informed by Elam that $7500.00 in cash had been deposited to the account in a night deposit facility and some mistake had evidently been made by the bank. Elam assured Cupp that they would “straighten it out.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.