Colorado Court of Appeals February 4, 1982, No. 81CA0285 (Mathews v. Urban)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-1982

KELLY, Judge.

Defendant, Ambrosio Urban, appeals the denial of his motion to set aside or modify a 1967 order reducing to judgment arrearages in child support. We reverse and remand.

In 1961, Mathews sued Urban for divorce in county court, seeking the maximum jurisdictional amount of $2,000. The county court entered a divorce decree and ordered Urban to pay $100 per month in child support until further order of the court. County court jurisdiction over the action was transferred to the district court in 1965. Colo.Const. Art. VI, See. 9(2). In 1967, Mathews obtained a district court order which reduced to judgment arrearages in child support payments in the amount of $6,116. Urban did not appeal this judgment.

In 1979, Mathews moved for appearance of the judgment debtor, and one month later, Urban moved to set aside the 1967 judgment. The trial court ruled that the 1961 child support order was valid and binding and that the 1967 order reducing ar-rearages to judgment was valid.

Mathews asserts that Urban may not challenge the 1967 judgment eleven years later because C.R.C.P. 60(b) requires that the motion be filed within six months of the judgment. However, since Urban claimed that the district court’s judgment exceeded its jurisdiction, the time limit of Rule 60(b) does not apply. McNeece v. McNeece, 39 Colo.App. 160, 562 P.2d 767 (1977); see Thompson v. McCormick, 138 Colo. 434, 335 P.2d 265 (1959).

Urban argues that the 1967 judgment exceeded the jurisdictional amount established by Mathews’ choice of the county court forum. He asserts that the judgment should be set aside, or in the alternative, reduced to $2,000.

Mathews contends that the judgment is valid because it was rendered by the district court, which has no jurisdictional limit. However, Mathews merely sought enforcement of the county court judgment in the district court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.