New York Court of Appeals February 23, 1982 (De Milio v. Borghard)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-02-1982

OPINION OF THE COURT

Gabrielli, J.

Presented for our determination is the question of whether the four-month limitations period in an article 78 proceeding brought by a probationary governmental employee to review his discharge commences to run from the termination date of his employment or from the date his request for reconsideration of his discharge is denied.

Petitioner was employed in a probationary capacity by the Westchester County Department of Environmental Facilities. By letter of October 12, 1979 from the commissioner of this department he was advised that his employment would be terminated on October 25,1979. In response to this notice of termination, petitioner first commenced an administrative grievance procedure in accordance with his union’s collective bargaining agreement, which proved unavailing. Petitioner also sent a letter to the commissioner on October 29, 1979 requesting that he reconsider the decision to terminate him, alleging that the commissioner had misconstrued certain facts underlying his decision. As alleged by petitioner, he received a negative response to this letter on or about November 15, 1979.

On March 5, 1980, petitioner commenced the present article 78 proceeding to review respondent’s determination terminating his employment. Special Term dismissed the petition on the ground that the proceeding was barred by the four-month limitations period specified by CPLR 217. In doing so, the court measured this period from October 25, 1979, the date on which petitioner’s probationary employment was terminated. The Appellate Division thereof*219ter affirmed, noting that petitioner’s application for reconsideration of an administrative decision did not extend the four-month limitations period, The dissenters below, however, concluded that this period should be measured from November 15,1979, the date on which petitioner’s demand for reinstatement was refused.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.