New York Court of Appeals May 18, 1982 (Greene v. Greene)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-05-1982

lead-opinion

OPINION OF THE COURT

Wachtler, J.

The plaintiff commenced this action against her former attorneys seeking (1) rescission of a trust agreement and (2) an accounting for mismanagement of the fund. On the defendants’ motion the trial court dismissed the rescission cause of action but the Appellate Division reversed. The defendants appeal by leave of the Appellate Division on a certified question concerning the correctness of its order.

Two primary issues are raised on the appeal: (1) whether the plaintiff has stated a cause of action for rescission and (2) whether the cause of action is barred by the Statute of Limitations. The latter issue also presents a question concerning the applicability of the “continuous treatment” doctrine to an attorney who drafts an agreement and then acts as trustee and attorney under the agreement.

In 1964, when she was a college sophomore, plaintiff received treatment for a mental illness at a New York City hospital. She remained a patient at that facility and a related one until 1967. While in those institutions plaintiff *90was approached by a family lawyer (not associated with the defendants) and at his urging signed a trust agreement, dated February 5, 1965, in which she virtually surrendered to him all management and control over her inheritance for her lifetime.

Upon her release from the hospital in 1967 the plaintiff retained the defendants to have the 1965 trust agreement set aside. The defendants commenced an action on her behalf in the Supreme Court and, in 1969, succeeded in having the 1965 trust agreement rescinded. In that action the court concluded that the attorney who drafted the agreement and later became the trustee, was chargeable with overreaching. The court noted in particular the plaintiff’s mental condition at the time the 1965 trust agreement was executed as well as her lack of experience in business and legal matters and ignorance of the content and effect of this agreement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.