New York Court of Appeals June 17, 1982 (In re of an Investigation into the Death of Jon L.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-06-1982

OPINION OF THE COURT

Fuchsberg, J.

One of the greatest contributions of American law may be the protection it affords the individual against the power of the government itself. However, the values this bespeaks often require a delicate balancing of the individual interest in privacy and dignity against circumstances which may call for intrusion by organized society. In this context, we now are called upon to determine the exr tremely sensitive issue of whether a suspect in a homicide investigation may be compelled, pursuant to court order, to supply the People with corporeal evidence, in this case in the form of a sample of his blood for scientific analysis.

The question has yielded diverse opinions in the lower courts of this State (compare, e.g., People v Vega, 51 AD2d 33; Matter of Alphonso C. [Morgenthau], 50 AD2d 97, app dsmd 38 NY2d 923; and Matter of Mackell v Palermo, 59 Misc 2d 760, with Matter of District Attorney of Kings *291County v Angelo G., 48 AD2d 576, app dsmd 38 NY2d 923; People v McClain, 88 Misc 2d 693; People v Mineo, 85 Misc 2d 919; and Matter of Merola v Fico, 81 Misc 2d 206; cf. People v Middleton, 54 NY2d 42 [postarrest order]). Not unexpectedly, it has troubled commentators as well (see, e.g., Note, Detention to Obtain Physical Evidence Without Probable Cause, 72 Col L Rev 712; Note, Constitutional Limitations on the Taking of Body Evidence, 78 Yale LJ 1074).

It is in this perspective that, for the reasons which follow, we hold a court order to obtain a blood sample of a suspect may issue provided the People establish (1) probable cause to believe the suspect has committed the crime, (2) a “clear indication” that relevant material evidence will be found, and (3) the method used to secure it is safe and reliable.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.