Court of Appeals of Georgia July 8, 1982, 63493 (Ryle v. Sliz)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-07-1982

lead-opinion

Shulman, Presiding Judge.

When appellees Sliz and Beauchene defaulted on a promissory note to appellant Ryle, Ryle filed suit for damages he purportedly sustained as a result of appellees’ alleged negligent breach of a private duty. Code Ann. § 105-104. Alleging stubborn litigiousness on the part of appellees, appellant also sought expenses of litigation pursuant to Code Ann. § 20-1404. This appeal stems from a jury verdict in favor of appellees and the denial of appellant’s motions for new trial and for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.

1. Because the excerpts from the trial transcript made a part of the appellate record by appellant do not present a sufficient basis from which this court can make a determination as to whether appellant was entitled to a directed verdict or judgment n.o.v., the rulings of the trial court on the two motions must be affirmed. However, we reverse the judgment entered on the jury verdict because of the admission of irrelevant, prejudicial testimony.

2. Appellant enumerates as error the admission of testimony from Wyche, appellant’s former business partner, concerning a conversation between them regarding a former lessee of property owned by appellant’s and Wyche’s business. Wyche testified, over objection, that Grady Smith, the former tenant, had died after three or four months’ occupancy and that Smith’s son had attempted to operate his late father’s business but had vacated the premises after falling behind in the rental payments. Wyche testified that Ryle wanted to sue the tenant’s widow for the unpaid rent but that Wyche, knowing the woman had a small child, refused. When appellant objected, questioning the relevance of the above-summarized testimony, counsel for appellees argued that the testimony was admissible to show that appellant was litigious, and that this was *869relevant in light of appellant’s allegation of stubborn litigiousness on the part of appellees.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.