Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York February 11, 1982 (People v. Feretti)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-02-1982

OPINION OF THE COURT

Per Curiam.

Defendant Thomas Feretti was convicted after a jury trial of robbery in the first degree for his complicity as the getaway driver in the robbery of a supermarket manager making a night bank deposit. Proof of guilt was strong and the conviction should not be disturbed. We take critical note, however, of the prosecutor’s repeated efforts to show the existence of a prior relationship between defendant, who lived just 10 blocks from the crime scene, and two of the detectives investigating the crime. Except for an initial denial of any involvement, defendant admitted during questioning, as he did in his trial testimony, that he had driven the two robbers to the bank and waited for them, *41according to their instructions, a few blocks away. He also admitted driving one of the robbers from the scene. His defense was that he did not know that a robbery was planned, and that he never joined the criminal enterprise as an accomplice.

In a pretrial Huntley hearing, Detective Roge had informed the court that he knew defendant from a prior arrest two months earlier for possession of stolen property. Although the specific arrest was never mentioned at trial, the prosecutor constantly reiterated the theme that defendant was known to Detectives Roge and Cohen. In her opening she told the jury “[a]nd you’ll hear Detective Roge testify that he knew the name Feretti *** And you’ll hear Detective [Roge] testify that he’d seen defendant in this case on prior occasions, he knew the defendant and he knew the car.” The prosecutor noted that Detective Cohen spoke to defendant at the precinct because he “knew this young man.”

On their direct examinations, the prosecutor repeatedly elicited the fact that each officer had known defendant prior to the incident.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.