Civil Court of the City of New York May 6, 1982 (Beslity v. Manhattan Honda)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-05-1982

OPINION OF THE COURT

David B. Saxe, J.

The issue that is raised in this Small Claims Court proceeding on the court’s own motion is as follows: Must a consumer who seeks relief under section 350-d of the General Business Law, a so-called “private Attorney General Statute” always bring an action for both damages and injunctive relief? If so, then a proceeding such as this one, under section 350-d of the General Business Law (as *889well as General Business Law, § 349, subd [h]) should be brought in the State Supreme Court and not in the Civil Court.

The following are the essential facts: The claimant is an attorney for the Legal Aid Society suing pro se. Defendant Manhattan Honda placed an advertisement in the automobile section of the Sunday New York Times of December 27, 1981. In large bold type, the ad began:

“$1,000 OFF*

“1982 ACCORD HATCHBACK”

Slightly below, in much smaller type was, first, a corresponding asterisk, followed by a detailed description of the car that was offered. As a discerning purchaser, the claimant Mr. Beslity, read each word carefully and concluded that the vehicle described was not an Accord Hatchback, but instead, an Accord Hatchback LX, the very car he wanted to buy! He came to the conclusion that the example in the ad was an LX model because it had equipment available only on the LX (i.e., variable-assist power steering). Armed with this information, he proceeded quickly to defendant Honda’s showroom to purchase the Honda LX with a $1,000 discount. A salesman informed him that the ad referred to a mere Hatchback, not the more exclusive LX. At trial, Honda indeed admitted that the description of the car in the ad was that of an LX and not a Hatchback, the result, of a copy-writing mistake.

The claimant purchased the LX model. Honda gave him a $750 discount based upon their offer in the same ad of “similar savings on other cars in stock.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.