New York Supreme Court June 7, 1982 (Beth Israel North Housing Co. v. Berman)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-06-1982

OPINION OF THE COURT

Richard W. Wallach, J.

The antagonists in this action for a declaratory judgment and motion for a temporary injunction are a limited profit housing company, Beth Israel North Housing Co., Inc., organized under the Private Housing Finance Law and the Commissioner of the State Division of Housing and Community Renewal. The issue (said by the Attorney-General to be one of first impression) is whether the commissioner can compel Beth Israel Hospital to exact an income questionnaire from its staff members who occupy the hospital campus housing project, with the object either to surcharge or evict those tenants whose incomes exceed certain máximums. The court holds that under the broad statutory scheme which regulates limited profit housing, the nurses, interns and other staff members who occupy the housing facility are not subject to those income limitations which must otherwise be met by persons of low income who *441occupy other housing facilities created under this law (cf. New York State Comr. of Housing & Community Renewal v Electchester First Housing Co., 113 Misc 2d 631).

Plaintiff’s certificate of incorporation was filed with the Department of State on August 11, 1966. It provides in relevant part as follows: “The purposes for which the Company is to be formed are to provide housing and auxiliary facilities for staff members, employees or students of Beth Israel Medical Center, New York, New York, and their immediate families or for aged persons of low income”.

In order to provide housing facilities for the hospital personnel of Beth Israel Medical Center, a not-for-profit tax exempt hospital, plaintiff company first financed with a public bond issue and they constructed the present housing facility containing 184 apartments with 652 rooms. Those housing accommodations are exclusively for nurses, interns, residents, and other hospital staff members.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.