New York Supreme Court June 1, 1982 (Lewkow v. Gracie Square Hospital)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-06-1982
OPINION OF THE COURT
Bentley Kassal, J.
This is a wrongful death action based upon alleged medical malpractice by decedent’s psychiatrist and the hospital wherein he received psychiatric treatment. Shortly after his discharge, he committed suicide. The plaintiff is the widow and legal representative of the decedent. Defendant contends that plaintiff’s psychiatric history and emotional relationship with the decedent are also at issue herein.
ISSUE
Does the commencement of this action by plaintiff, as a distributee and personal representative of the decedent’s estate constitute a waiver of her doctor-patient privilege in regard to her own mental and physical condition?
DECISION
CPLR 4504 (subd [a]) states that the doctor-patient privilege is to apply “[ujnless the patient waives the privi*733lege”. There is a waiver effected by a plaintiff bringing an action where plaintiff’s physical condition is in issue. (Burgos v Flower & Fifth Ave. Hosp., 108 Misc 2d 225.) However, absent a waiver of this privilege, the medical records, even if they may be relevant and material, are not subject to disclosure (supra, p 226).
I carefully note the clear distinctions made by Mr. Justice Stecher in the Burgos case (supra), between the medical histories of (a) the infant plaintiff, which was disclosed, (b) the plaintiff’s siblings, disclosure of which was denied, and (c) the mother of the infant, which was allowed to be disclosed in part only. Mrs. Burgos’ personal medical history during the period the infant was in útero was disclosed, since there could be “no severance of a mother from child” (supra, p 226). But, the court firmly stated that, with that exception, there was no waiver of any other privilege involving Mrs. Burgos’ physicians.
Analysis of the instant case does show that the plaintiff’s status is (1) as a nominal party, as a legal representative, and (2) an actual party, as a distributee under EPTL 5-4.1.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit