Civil Court of the City of New York July 2, 1982 (Palmer v. Safe Auto Sales, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-07-1982

OPINION OF THE COURT

David B. Saxe, J.

The issue that I must resolve in this small claims case is: Whether a modification of a contract between a merchant and a consumer for the sale of a new automobile under which the consumer is obligated to pay an increased price over that specified in the original contract of sale to be entitled to obtain delivery and possession of the vehicle, is a bad-faith modification of the original contract under the provisions of the Uniform Commercial Code which, may accordingly entitle the buyer to recover damages.

The essential facts are not in dispute. On February 6, 1980, Dr. Leonard Palmer, an optometrist who lives in the Manhattan Beach section of Brooklyn, New York, entered into a contract for the purchase of a 1980 Toyota Tercel, deluxe model with Safe Auto Sales, Inc. of Coney Island *965Avenue in Brooklyn. The total price of the car was $5,822.04. Dr. Palmer paid a $100 deposit, the balance to be paid at the time of delivery. During the second week of March, 1980, Dr. Palmer was informed that a car was available which included a rear wiper not specified in the original agreement. In other respects, the car conformed to the contract. Safe Auto told Dr. Palmer that if he wanted to take delivery of the car, he would have to pay an additional charge for the rear wiper. Dr. Palmer was also informed that a “body molding” not agreed upon in the written agreement was added to the car in stock and would cost an additional $45, if desired. On March 18, 1980, Dr. Palmer accepted and paid for a 1980 Toyota Tercel Model 1382 including rear wiper, totaling $75, body molding totaling $45, as well as a price adjustment of $150 reflecting the increase in cost to the dealer between the time of ordering and date of delivery together with applicable sales tax. Dr. Palmer claims that he has been overcharged by the defendant in the amount of $291 representing the costs of the two additional items, the price increase and the additional tax.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.