New York County Courts November 24, 1982 (People v. Talbert)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-11-1982

OPINION OF THE COURT

Joseph Harris, J.

Defendant moves to suppress tangible property, consisting of cocaine and marihuana, seized from his person by the police as an incident to his arrest.

Defendant was a passenger in an automobile stopped by a trooper of the New York State Police on the New York State Thruway for speeding. While seeking to check the driver’s registration and operator’s license, the trooper spied a “stick” 24 to 30 inches in length, taped on both ends, located on the floor of the car between the front seat and front door. Pursuant to his training in the New York State Police, the trooper identified the instrument as a “billy”, the possession of which is prohibited by subdivision (1) of section 265.01 of the Penal Law, criminal possession of a weapon in the fourth degree, and arrested all occupants of the car for possession of said “weapon.”

The sole question raised herein is whether the instrument involved is a “billy” within the purview of subdivision (1) of section 265.01 of the Penal Law.

*772More and more it seems that the only thing certain in the criminal law is that there are no simple answers to simple questions. The instrument in question had previously been part of a broomhandle, sawed-off to approximately 24 to 30 inches in length, and taped at both ends — obviously to provide a palm grip. In its original manufactured state it was part of an implement for sweeping floors; in its revised form it lost all capability for that purpose, unless one wished to take the unrealistic approach that it was capable of being used to beat up on recalcitrant dirt.

One of the recognized definitions of a “billy” is “a club; especially, a policeman’s club” (Black’s Law Dictionary [4th ed], p 213; People v Schoonmaker, 40 AD2d 1066). In Schoonmaker (supra), the Appellate Division, Third Department, concluded that the determinative factor controlling the classification of an instrument as a “billy” was the purpose for which it was designed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.