Superior Court of Pennsylvania July 9, 1982, No. 57 (Hallstrom Development Co. v. Lee)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-07-1982
MONTEMURO, Judge:
Appellees, Asbury W. Lee, IV, (“Lee”), H. R. Obleman (“Obleman”) and Roger L. Hughes (“Hughes”) filed suit in equity against the Clearfield Area Housing Corporation and Clearfield County Housing Authority (“Housing Authorities”) seeking to enjoin construction of a federally financed low income housing project. In said action in equity, the appellees contended that construction of the housing project constituted a nuisance and would diminish the value of their respective residences. Although the three residence properties were owned by the entireties, the wives of the appellees, Carolyn B. Lee, Gloria W. Obleman and Pauline L. Hughes, were not named as parties in the equity action. At the close of the appellees’ testimony, the lower court on motion of the “Housing Authorities” entered a nonsuit as to the appellee “Hughes” who did not appear for trial and who never pursued his cause of action. The case proceeded as to the two remaining plaintiff-appellees, “Lee” and “Obleman,” and at the conclusion of the trial, the court entered an order enjoining the development of the project. The “Housing Authorities” appealed that order to the Commonwealth Court. In reversing the order of the lower court, the Commonwealth Court1 entered the following order:
The Order of the court below is reversed and the complaint and amended complaint are dismissed. Costs on appellees, H. R. Obleman and Asbury W. Lee, IV.
In footnote 3 of its opinion, the Commonwealth Court noted that the court below had granted the “Housing Authority’s” motion for a compulsory nonsuit against appellee “Hughes” at close of the appellees’ case and that he did not participate further in the litigation.
After entry of the decision by the Commonwealth Court, the “Housing Authority” filed with the Prothonotary’s Office a bill of costs in the amount of $9004.50 to which no exceptions were entered by appellees, “Lee” and “Obleman”. Those costs were never reduced to judgment.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit