Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania March 12, 1982, Appeal, No. 7 T.D. 1981 (City Firefighters' Ass'n v. City of Philadelphia)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-1982

Opinion by President

Judge Crum'Lish, Jr.,

The City Firefighters’ Association of Philadelphia1 appeals a Philadelphia Common Pleas Court decision which sustained the preliminary objections of the City of Philadelphia and its officers.2 We affirm.

In March of 1980 the City laid off 256 members of the Philadelphia Fire Department due to an impending fiscal crisis. The Firefighters assert, based on certain provisions of the Philadelphia Home Rule Charter, that these layoffs are illegal and were not made in good faith.

The Home Rule Charter provides in pertinent part:

Section 4-100 Chief Executive Officer.

The Mayor shall be the chief executive officer of the City. He shall be responsible for the conduct of the executive and administrative work of the City and for law enforcement within its boundaries.

Section 4-101 Finances.

The Mayor shall:

(e) See to it that the City does not, except in case of unforeseeable emergency, incur a deficit in any fiscal year.3

*286Under the above provisions of the Home Rule Charter, the Mayor may not incur a fiscal deficit unless such deficit is in response to an unforeseeable emergency. However, the Firefighters contend that Section 5-4004 of the Home Rule Charter limits the Mayor’s ability to use layoffs of firemen as a means to avert such a deficit.

Section 5-400 Functions.

The Fire Department shall have the power and its duty shall be to perform the following functions:

(d) Maintenance of firemen. The Department shall train, equip, maintain, supervise and discipline an adequate number of firemen.

(Emphasis added.)

The Firefighters asserted that the layoffs leave the City without an “adequate number of firemen” in violation of the Home Rule Charter and requested the lower court to order the City and the Mayor (1) “to set minimum manning levels for the Fire Department,” (2) to meet these levels, and (3) to enjoin the City from violating their “duty to make the .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.