Massachusetts Appeals Court August 18, 1982 (Commonwealth v. O'Neil)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-08-1982

When the assault on the victims — two boys — occurred, they were eleven and twelve years old. They had broken off from a group attending *979a Red Sox game and, shortly before midnight, found themselves lost and penniless in Charlestown. Two men came along and offered them a place to sleep for the night; the assaults followed shortly after in a laundry room of an apartment complex. The boys found an opportunity to run from the scene and, now naked (one had underwear shorts, the other was trying to cover up with newspaper), rang the nearest available doorbell. An astonished — and somewhat wary — householder found two naked and whimpering boys on her doorstep. Police were summoned. The victims gave descriptions of both assailants and described the defendant as follows: wearing a blue windbreaker, jeans, acne all over the front of his face, dirty blond hair, hazel or brown eyes, and a chipped tooth on the side.

Information of the assault and descriptions given by the victims went out over police radio. An officer in a cruiser observed a person answering one of the descriptions coming out of a convenience store and followed him to a house which the suspect entered. This turned out to be the defendant’s home. Meanwhile, the victims were reviewing mug shots at police headquarters and found no pictures which fit their assailants. Alerted by the officer who had followed the defendant, two detectives and two patrolmen set out with the victims in a cruiser to the O’Neil home. When the defendant came down the stairs, one of the victims said, “That’s him.” The other victim recognized the defendant’s voice when he spoke. The defendant fit the description the boys had given: he had a chipped tooth, severe acne, dirty blond hair and brown eyes.

The grounds which the defendant now urges for suppression are that the identification procedure was improperly suggestive.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.