Court of Appeals of Arizona December 9, 1982, No. 2 CA-CIV 4486 (Janes v. Country Escrow Service)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-12-1982

OPINION

HATHAWAY, Judge.

This controversy has been before us previously and we remanded for a new trial on the issues of breach of contract and conversion. Country Escrow Service v. Janes, 121 Ariz. 511, 591 P.2d 999 (App.1979). The breach of contract count was dismissed and trial proceeded on the remaining issue, the Janes’ claim for conversion. The jury returned a verdict in their favor in the sum of $7,741.29 compensatory damages, and $110,-000 punitive damages. Motions for judgment n.o.v., or in the alternative, for new trial, were denied and this appeal followed.

Appellant Edward Chesin operated the El Capri Shopping Center in which the Janes leased a space for their women’s clothing store. The lease commenced on September 1, 1975, and was for a five-year term. On January 3, 1976, Chesin excluded the Janes from the premises for failure to pay the rent for the months of December 1975 and January 1976. The locks on the doors were changed and Chesin filed suit against the Janes for the unpaid rent. The Janes answered and counterclaimed alleging that by retaking possession of the store and the property located therein, Chesin had converted the Janes’ property, primarily merchandise.

Appellants first contend on appeal that the judgment rendered on the complaint established as a matter of law that the Janes had breached the lease contract. Their complaint alleged that the Janes had breached their contract by failing to make the rental payments and specifically alleged:

“V

Defendants have failed to make the agreed rental payments for the months of December, 1975, and January, 1976.

VI

Pursuant to the terms of the above-described lease, plaintiff advised defendants of their breach of the lease and demanded payment of the rent due and owing.

VII

Defendants failed and refused to pay said rent and have thereby breached the described lease.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.