Court of Appeals of Arizona August 19, 1982, No. 1 CA-CIV 5411 (Word v. Motorola, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-08-1982

OPINION

RICHARD M. DAVIS, Judge, Pro Tern.

The question presented by this appeal from a summary judgment is whether the appellee manufacturer conclusively demonstrated that it was the “statutory employer” of a workmen’s compensation recipient so as to bar his third party tort action under the exclusive remedy rule. We hold that it did, and affirm.

Appellant alleges an injury at a plant facility of Motorola’s Government Electronics Division on April 10, 1978. Appellant, a sheet metal worker, was hanging air-conditioning ductwork at the time. The duct-work installation was part of a major remodeling of the “1500 area” within the Motorola plant. Appellant was climbing on an elevating device called an Econolift and he alleged that a portion of it slipped, resulting in an injury to his knee.

Appellant was employed by Paramount Design Systems, Inc., at the time of the incident. Paramount was one of four or five companies which were under contract to supply laborers to Motorola. Appellant had been “hired” or accepted to work at Motorola in March of 1978 by Gary Skelton, a foreman in Motorola’s construction and maintenance department. Ronald Zardus was manager of the department. Damon Begley was the supervisor between Zardus and Skelton. Ira Abel was a sheet metal worker employed by Motorola. He worked on the second, or night, shift. Appellant was hired as a “helper” for Abel. All of appellant’s work orders and supervision came from Motorola personnel, principally Abel. Just prior to April 10, Skelton and other Motorola supervisory personnel had made a decision to terminate appellant’s services. They were dissatisfied with his performance. The reason given to appellant was that work was getting slow.

Under Paramount’s contact with Motorola, Paramount had no specified operating duties beyond the duty of supplying a variety of types of workmen to Motorola — the latter’s request.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.