Hawaii Supreme Court June 30, 1982, NO. 8020 (In re the Tax Appeal of Pacific Machinery, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-06-1982
Per Curiam.
This is an appeal from a judgment of the Tax Appeal Court in favor of the taxpayer. Section 237-20, HRS, is entitled “Principles applicable in certain situations.” The last sentence of that section reads:
The reimbursement of costs or advances made for or on behalf of one person by another shall not constitute gross income of the latter, unless the person receiving such reimbursement also receives additional monetary consideration for making such costs or advances.
In In Re Island Holidays, Ltd., 59 Haw. 307 at 315, 582 P.2d 703 (1978), we stated with respect to that statute:
Each sentence of the section provides a rule to be applied to a situation in which it may be unclear whether a transaction involves one or more than one taxable entity.
The parties agree that the question in this case is whether the appellee is liable for the general excise tax assessed on reimbursement received by it from Caterpillar Tractor Company for advertising expenses.
Appellee sells heavy equipment. Caterpillar manufactures some of that equipment. The court below found that under a cooperative *46advertising agreement, the appellee invoiced Caterpillar for 50% of the amounts billed to the appellee by third persons for pre-approved advertising of products manufactured by Caterpillar. The court further found that the invoicing to Caterpillar did not include any costs for overhead, salaries, or other internal expenses or profit incurred by the appellee, nor were there payments for services performed in advertising Caterpillar products, or reimbursement for internal costs incurred by appellee in connection with advertising Caterpillar products.
Allan S. Chock, Deputy Attorney General, on the briefs for appellant, Department of Taxation.
Michael A. Shea and C. Michael Hare (Cades, Schutte, Fleming & Wright, of counsel) for appellee, Pacific Machinery.
These findings are supported by the stipulation as to facts entered by the parties.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit