Court of Appeals of Arkansas May 5, 1982, CA 81-248 (Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. of Arkansas v. Smith)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-05-1982
Melvin Mayfield, Chief Judge.
The appellant, Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company, was sued on a homeowners policy and the jury returned a verdict for the company. This appeal is from the granting of a motion for new trial. We find the motion should not have been granted.
Appellees’ motion was based on an allegation of juror misconduct consisting of a statement said to have been made by one of the jurors during jury deliberations. The motion was accompanied by the affidavit of a juror who also testified at the hearing on the motion. While it is not entirely clear from the appellant’s abstract (there is no supplemental abstract by the appellees), we accept the assertion in appel-lees’ brief that the affidavit and testimony by the one juror was that the other juror said “it’s lawsuits like this that will make all our insurance premiums go up.”
In its order granting a new trial, the court said while the testimony did not prove that appellees did not receive a fair trial, “with this shadow over the jury’s deliberations it cannot be said plaintiffs did receive a fair trial.”
The appellant objected to the trial court’s consideration of the juror’s affidavit and to the introduction of the juror’s testimony at the hearing. The admissibility of such evidence is governed by our Uniform Rules of Evidence 606 (b), which states:
(b) Inquiry into Validity of Verdict or Indictment.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit