United States Court of International Trade April 30, 1982, Court No. 73-4-00898 (Schoenfeld & Sons, Inc. v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-04-1982
Landis, Judge:
Pursuant to Rule 56 of this Court plaintiff moves and defendant cross-moves for summary judgment.
The subject merchandise of this action is dehydrated green bell peppers. The pertinent tariff provisions, found in the Tariff Schedules of the United States (TSUS), are as follows:
Classified under:
Schedule 1. — Animal and Vegetable Products
PART 8. — VEGETABLES
*******
Subpart B. — Vegetables, Dried, Desiccated, or Dehydrated
Vegetables, dried, desiccated, or dehydrated, whether or not reduced in size or reduced to flour (but not otherwise prepared or preserved):
Dried desiccated or dehydrated:
*124140.55 Other 15.5% ad val. or 13.5% ad val., depending on year of entry
Claimed under:
PART II [SCHEDULE l] — COFFEE, TEA, MATE, AND SPICES *******
Subpart B. — Spices and Spice Seeds
Subpart B headnotes:
1. The articles described in this subpart embrace only such herbs, leaves, flowers, barks, roots, seeds, or other parts of plants which have practically no food value, and are suited and capable of being directly used, either whole, divided or ground, for culinary purposes as a seasoning or garnishment.
*******
Pepper:
*******
Capsicum or cayenne or red:
Not ground:
*******
161.83 1 Other 4$ per lb. or 3$ per lb. depending on year of entry
A review of the pleadings and the memorandums of law, affidavits and exhibits submitted in support of the summary judgment motions indicates that this action is not ripe for granting summary judgment to either party as material issues of fact exist which should be resolved on a full trial on the merits. It is well settled that the existence of material issues of fact precludes the granting of summary judgment. S.S. Kresge Co. v. United States, 77 Cust. Ct. 154, C.R.D. 76-6 (1976); Inter-Pacific Corp. v. United States, 1 CIT *125338, Slip Op. 81-52 (1981). The court cannot try issues of fact on a summary judgment motion, it can only determine whether there are factual issues to be tried. Heyman v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit