New York County Court, Montgomery County August 5, 1982, No. 82-TR-D-1253 (Village of Brookville v. Louthan)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-08-1982

FROELich, J.

The stipulated facts in this case include that the complaining witness was an off-duty municipal police officer in a private unmarked vehicle, although in uniform, and on his way home from work when he observed the defendant within the cify limits violate a city traffic ordinance. The defendant contends, first, that since the complaining witness was off-duty, he was not authorized to make an arrest. Secondly, the defendant contends, that he was arrested. Thirdly, the defendant contends that even if he were lawfully arrested, R.C. 4549.14 and Evid. R. 601(C) make the officer incompetent to testify.

This court can find no controlling cases on the authority of an “off-duty” police officer. In State v. Maxwell (1978), 60 Ohio Misc. 1 [14 O.O.3d 44], the Miamisburg Municipal Court said that an officer is not on duty twenty-four hours a day, but may by his actions act as a police officer. In that instance, the court held that the officer came on duty for the specific purpose of enforcing the traffic laws at the point in time when he began to act like a police officer and exercised his power as a police officer. Since the question of whether an officer was “on-duty” or “off-duty” will rarely arise unless the officer “acts like a police officer,” it seems to be a distinction without a difference to suggest that an officer is not on duty during all the hours under which he is under an obligation to follow his or her oath to preserve the peace, protect persons and property, and obey and enforce all ordinances of the city (see, e.g., R.C. 737.11).

*2Secondly, this court finds that an arrest was made. This court is well aware of the Ohio appellate case law holding that a traffic citation is not an arrest. However, in the case sub judice, the complaining witness followed the defendant to his home and then had the defendant follow him back to the police station at which time he was cited.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.