Ohio Supreme Court February 24, 1982, No. 81-829 (State ex rel. Ohio Precision Castings v. Bohman)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-02-1982

lead-opinion

Per Curiam.

The decedent was employed in the heat treatment department of appellant’s facility. There, hot castings are removed from an oven and submerged in a tank containing water heated in excess of 150 degrees Fahrenheit. The tank is recessed into the floor except for 12 inches which extend above floor level. Located at the rear of the tank is a gas oven. Standard guardrailing was positioned in front of the tank; however, guardrailing had not been erected along either side of the tank. Two steel doors are hinged on opposite sides of the tank, each of which serves to cover one-half of the tank when closed. At the time of the injury, one steel door was raised extending to a vertical height of 42 inches.

The commission, in granting the specific safety requirement violation award, found that the decedent’s death occurred as a result of appellant’s failure to comply with IC-5-02.03(E), which provides, in pertinent part:

“OPEN VATS, OPEN SOAKING PITS AND OPEN TANKS

“Sides of such vats, soaking pits, and tanks, containing injurious chemicals or materials over 150° F. in temperature, shall extend to a height of not less than thirty-six (36) inches above the working floor level or shall be guarded by standard guard railing. Employees shall not be required to work over such vats, soaking pits and tanks except on elevated runways, platforms, and walkways * * * .”

Appellant argues that since IC-5-02.03 is titled “PERMANENT OPENINGS-FLOOR, WALL AND YARD,” its application extends only to those vats and tanks which are con*393tinuously open and not to the tank in question which was open for only 30 minutes daily. We disagree.

The regulation refers to permanent openings in contrast to those openings which are temporary in nature. The interval of time in which the tank is used is irrelevant when determining its permanency.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.