Ohio Supreme Court April 21, 1982, No. 81-820 (Builders Ass'n v. Commercial Piping Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-04-1982

Krupansky, J.

The issue here is whether the National Labor Relations Act preempts an action brought in a state court to compel arbitration of a dispute between an employer and an employers’ association over the employer’s execution of a separate agreement with a union, allegedly in violation of an agreement between the employer and the association.

The association contends this is merely an action for breach of contract over which the state court may exercise *11jurisdiction. Commercial argues this controversy is within the exclusive jurisdiction of the board.

The doctrine of preemption in labor law was developed to prevent state court interference with the federal regulatory scheme. The overriding goal of preemption has been to promote a uniform application of the Act by a centralized administrative agency, thereby avoiding “potential conflict of rules of law, of remedy, and of administration,” promulgated by different tribunals. San Diego Building Trades Council v. Garmon (1959), 359 U. S. 236, 242. The focus of inquiry when an issue of federal preemption arises has been the extent to which state court adjudication would interfere with a uniform national labor policy as administered by the board. See, e.g., Local 100, United Association of Journeymen & Apprentices v. Borden (1963), 373 U. S. 690. Accordingly, the critical inquiry is “whether the controversy presented to the state court is identical to * * * or different from * * * that which could have been, but was not, presented to the Labor Board. For it is only in the former situation that a state court’s exercise of jurisdiction necessarily involves a risk of interference with the unfair labor practice jurisdiction of the Board * * * .” (Emphasis added.) Sears Roebuck & Co. v. San Diego County District Council of Carpenters (1978), 436 U. S. 180, 197.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.