Ohio Supreme Court July 14, 1982, No. 81-1831 (East Ohio Gas Co. v. Public Utilities Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-07-1982

Per Curiam.

Appellant argues that the commission erred in allowing only partial recovery of its advertising expenses.1 The seminal case regarding the recovery of advertising expenses by a public utility is Cleveland v. Pub. Util. Comm. (1980), 63 Ohio St. 2d 62 [17 O.O. 3d 37]. In Cleveland, this court stated, at page 70, that there are essentially four types of utility advertising: institutional, promotional, informational and conservational. Regarding institutional and promotional advertising, the court stated in the syllabus:

*32“Unless a utility can demonstrate that its institutional and promotional advertising expenditures and its charitable contributions provide a direct, primary benefit to its customers, such expense items are not allowable as operating expenses for rate-making purposes.”

In the present appeal, appellant does not argue that the commission erred in finding that the disallowed advertising was promotional or institutional. Rather, appellant’s position is that its consumers receive a “direct, primary benefit” from the advertising.

The thrust of this argument is that with decontrol and higher prices, gas is once again plentiful; however, the increased cost of gas has caused appellant to lose customers.2 As appellant has certain fixed costs, the loss of customers will result in those remaining bearing greater proportionate shares. The argument continues that it is necessary to advertise in order to maintain load factors and keep prices down. Therefore, customers are direct and primary beneficiaries of this advertising.

We cannot accept appellant’s argument. Even assuming customers derive a benefit from utility advertising, we must conclude that they do not receive a direct and primary benefit from the advertising. At best, appellant’s customers receive indirect benefits from the advertising. This is precisely what Cleveland, supra, held not to be includable as expense items for rate-making purposes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.